When Maya’s supervisor asks whether anyone has questions, Maya has one ready. Two assignments are due on Friday, and she needs to know which to finish first. She starts to speak, feels her throat tighten, and lets the moment pass. There’s relief as the meeting moves on. By midafternoon she has switched between the two assignments three times and still has to guess which one matters more.
Key Definition:
A CBT case formulation is a working explanation that therapist and client build together about how a difficulty may have developed and what keeps it going. They draw on recent experiences, relevant history, current circumstances, coping responses, and strengths to decide what to focus on. They revise the explanation as they learn more (Wenzel et al., 2016).
Table of Contents
What a Case Formulation Explains
In this fictional example, Maya brings that meeting to therapy because the difficulty getting clear priorities keeps spilling into the rest of her day. “I stay quiet in meetings” describes something she does. A diagnosis, when relevant, identifies a broader pattern of symptoms. A formulation asks what might explain the difficulty for Maya, in the settings where it occurs, and what might help. The answer can shape what she and her therapist work on together (Wenzel et al., 2016).
The therapist knows some of the ways people get stuck in patterns. Maya knows what happens in her meetings and what she has already tried. They compare what each knows and look at specific examples to see whether their explanation fits. In CBT, that shared work is called collaborative empiricism (Kuyken et al., 2008).
Start With One Recent Situation
What Happened and What It Meant
Maya recalls that the supervisor invited questions and that nobody spoke before the meeting moved on. When the therapist asks what she expected would happen if she asked hers, Maya remembers thinking, “I should have worked this out myself. He’ll make me explain why I haven’t.” The invitation was something the supervisor said. The expectation was Maya’s reading of what might happen next. Her tight throat and embarrassment were also part of the experience.
Starting with a specific situation gives therapist and client something they can examine together. They can ask what the client noticed, what it meant to them, how they felt, what they did, and what followed. Those details can influence one another. Maya might notice the tension in her throat before she can put the expectation into words (Wenzel et al., 2016).
What Staying Quiet Accomplished
As the meeting ends, the tension eases. Maya can turn her attention elsewhere for a moment. Later, she has two unfinished tasks and still needs a decision. The therapist wonders whether that immediate relief makes Maya more likely to put off asking the next time. This is a possibility to explore in Maya’s case (Craske, 2010).
The function of a coping response depends on the circumstances. Keeping quiet may protect someone from being singled out in front of colleagues. It can also leave them with a question they still need answered. Looking at what the response achieves in the moment and what follows makes room for both possibilities (Craske, 2010; Hofmann & Hay, 2018).
What History and Present Circumstances Add
Why Speaking Up Felt Risky
At a previous job, Maya was criticized in front of her team for asking a question about an unfamiliar procedure. She began preparing more thoroughly before meetings and saving questions for people she trusted. That experience gives her and her therapist one possible account of why an invitation to speak can still feel risky. The connection is worth exploring even if neither can pinpoint when the expectation took hold.
The therapist also asks what has happened in Maya’s current team. Maya has heard this supervisor dismiss a colleague’s question in front of the group. She has two genuinely competing deadlines and little authority to move either. What happened at the old job may help explain why public criticism comes quickly to mind. What happens at this job affects the risks she faces now. A formulation can take account of both (Wenzel et al., 2016).
What Changes With a Trusted Colleague
Maya regularly asks a trusted colleague direct questions about how to do a task. She can explain what information she is missing and listen to the answer without much hesitation. The colleague can help her work out a procedure but cannot decide which assignment takes priority. The exception gives the therapist a reason to narrow the explanation. It also shows a skill Maya already has and a limit on what that skill can accomplish in this setting.
Kuyken and colleagues’ approach to formulation puts client strengths alongside difficulties from the beginning. A situation that goes differently can help therapist and client see which part of a pattern depends on the setting and identify what the client can draw on (Kuyken et al., 2008).
How a Working Explanation Guides the Next Step
State the Hypothesis Together
The therapist offers a draft in ordinary language. “It sounds as though expecting criticism makes it harder to ask in the meeting. Staying quiet feels safer in the moment, and then you’re left trying to guess which job comes first. Does that fit?” Maya agrees that the public part feels right. She pauses over the suggestion that staying quiet leaves her without an answer.
Asking Maya how the explanation fits gives them a chance to correct it before it guides the next step. They also agree on what would count as progress. Maya wants to spend less time guessing and to know which assignment comes first, even if asking still feels uncomfortable. An agreed goal gives the client’s priorities a place in the plan and makes later feedback easier to interpret (Wenzel et al., 2016).
What Evidence Would Test the Explanation
They can start with exchanges that have already occurred. If postponing her questions is a major reason priorities stay unclear, asking early should sometimes lead to a decision she can use. Looking back gives them a way to learn more without asking Maya to take on more risk in a meeting (Craske, 2010).
Her emails offer a place to start. When she asks early, does she get an answer in time to act on it?
What Would Change the Formulation
What the Therapist Missed
“I do ask,” Maya says. “I usually email him the same day. Last week I asked on Monday and he told me everything was urgent.” She brings up two other examples. In one, the reply came after she had already picked a task. In the other, she got a clear answer and was able to finish the priority assignment. The therapist’s first explanation covered the silence in meetings and assumed too much about what happened afterward.
How the Revised Explanation Changes the Plan
They revise the explanation together. Expecting criticism still helps explain why Maya holds back in meetings. Inconsistent direction helps explain why she has to guess even when she asks. She can use a clear answer when it comes in time. The two parts of the problem call for different questions. Maya and her therapist can explore when speaking in a meeting feels possible and what might help her get a usable decision from someone with authority to set priorities.
If her team has a feasible way to confirm priorities, they could see whether it gets Maya an answer before she commits time to either assignment. In a later session, they could ask whether she spent less time switching between tasks, even if asking still felt uncomfortable (Wenzel et al., 2016).
If Maya cannot use the agreed way to ask, the plan itself may need adjusting. If she can use it and the same difficulty persists, they can ask what their explanation still misses (Wenzel et al., 2016; Kuyken et al., 2008).
What the Research Can Tell Us
Maya’s example shows how a formulation can guide the next decision. Researchers ask whether therapists agree about what belongs in a formulation, whether it fits a particular person’s experience, and whether it helps treatment. A review of 24 studies found that agreement was more consistent when researchers used structured methods and gave therapists more detail about the case. Much of the research focused on assessment. A written case summary captures only part of what happens when a client can correct the therapist or describe how a plan worked (Easden & Kazantzis, 2018).
Fit can be examined one person at a time. In a published clinical illustration, one client completed brief end-of-day questionnaires so the researchers could check whether the expected links between particular thoughts and distress appeared in that person’s reports. That approach helps examine a specific explanation for an individual (Mumma & Fluck, 2016).
The review found inconsistent evidence that putting more emphasis on formulation improved outcomes. One difficulty was telling the approaches apart. Therapists following a standard CBT protocol may also use a formulation and adapt their work to the person (Easden & Kazantzis, 2018).
A later study looked at adults receiving CBT in routine practice. Researchers examined periods when scores on a depression measure had stopped improving or had worsened. Those periods were more likely to resolve when the clinical record included a written formulation. The study leaves open whether the formulation itself accounted for the difference (Persons et al., 2026).
A Few Words by Psychology Fanatic
Maya’s question was ready before her supervisor moved on. When her therapist learned she had already put similar questions in writing, they could see where the difficulty continued after she spoke up.
There is room in a good working explanation for the client to say, “There’s something else you should know.” What comes next may change which part of the difficulty they work on together. Sometimes the first useful change is in what the two of them understand.
Associated Concepts
- Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: The broader therapy approach in which an individualized formulation can guide treatment.
- Avoidance Coping: How stepping away from discomfort can bring relief, protect someone, or carry longer-term costs.
- Feedback Loops: How the consequences of a response can shape what happens the next time the situation arises.
- Cognitive Distortions: Recurring ways of interpreting events that therapist and client can examine against available evidence.
- Cognitive Reappraisal: How a different reading of a situation can change its emotional meaning.
- Regulatory Flexibility: How a person can adjust a coping response as circumstances and feedback change.
References
Craske, Michelle G. (2010). Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy. American Psychological Association. ISBN: 9781433805486
(Return to Main Text)
Easden, Michael H.; Kazantzis, Nikolaos (2018). Case conceptualization research in cognitive behavior therapy: A state of the science review. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 74(3), 356–384. DOI: 10.1002/jclp.22516
(Return to Main Text)
Hofmann, Stefan G.; Hay, Aleena C. (2018). Rethinking avoidance: Toward a balanced approach to avoidance in treating anxiety disorders. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 55, 14–21. DOI: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2018.03.004
(Return to Main Text)
Kuyken, Willem; Padesky, Christine A.; Dudley, Robert (2008). The Science and Practice of Case Conceptualization. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 36(6), 757–768. DOI: 10.1017/S1352465808004815
(Return to Main Text)
Mumma, Gregory H.; Fluck, Jonathan (2016). How valid is your case formulation? Empirically testing your cognitive behavioural case formulation for tailored treatment. The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist, 9, e12. DOI: 10.1017/S1754470X16000088
(Return to Main Text)
Persons, Jacqueline B.; Zieve, Garret G.; Kreit, Griffin P. (2026). Therapist Use of a Case Formulation Is Associated With the Resolution but Not Prevention of Episodes of Symptom Deterioration and Lack of Progress During Cognitive Behavior Therapy. Behavior Therapy. Advance online publication. DOI: 10.1016/j.beth.2026.07.003
(Return to Main Text)
Wenzel, Amy; Dobson, Keith S.; Hays, Pamela A. (2016). Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Techniques and Strategies. American Psychological Association. ISBN: 9781433822377
(Return to Main Text)
Updated: November 18, 2026

