The Illusion of Objectivity: Understanding Subjective Reality

In a world brimming with diverse perspectives and experiences, the concept of subjective reality plays a pivotal role in shaping our understanding of human behavior and cognition. Each individual perceives the world through their unique lens, colored by emotions, beliefs, past encounters, and cultural backgrounds. This intricate tapestry of personal interpretation not only influences how we perceive events but also impacts our interactions with others. By delving into the nuances of subjective reality, we can better appreciate the profound differences that exist in the way people interpret similar experiences.

As we navigate life’s complexities, it becomes essential to recognize that our realities are not merely reflections of an objective truth but rather constructs shaped by our psychological filters. From emotional states affecting perception to cognitive biases skewing judgment, understanding these dynamics reveals why two individuals may experience the same event in vastly different ways. This exploration invites us to embrace empathy and open-mindedness as we engage with others’ subjective realities—ultimately enriching both our social connections and personal growth within this multifaceted human experience.

Basics of Subjective Reality

When examining subjective reality, it is essential to consider the role of perception. Our sensory organs receive information from the environment, which is then processed by the brain to create our perception of reality. However, this process is not purely objective, as our previous experiences and expectations can significantly impact how we interpret sensory input. For example, two people may witness the same event but perceive it differently based on their subjective reality.

The Hard Problem

Our subjective reality is intimately related to what analytical philosophy refers to as the “hard problem of consciousness.” David Dubrovsky explains “It is this quality that is the main stumbling block for its scientific explanation that subjective reality is the reality of the conscious states of the individual, which directly certifies for him that he exists.” Dubrovsky adds that consciousness has “a specific and inalienable quality of subjective reality.” In philosophical and psychological literature, the quality of subjective reality may be referred to with terms such as “mental”, “introspective”, “phenomenal”, “subjective experience”, “qualia”, etc.” (Dubrovsky, 2019).

Interpretation and Subjective Reality

Michael Gazzaniga, a prominent neuroscientist known for his extensive research in cognitive neuroscience, wrote, “The dominant left hemisphere is committed to the task of interpreting our overt behaviors as well as the more covert emotional responses produced by these separate mental modules of our brain. It constructs theories as to why these behaviors occurred and does so because of that brain system’s need to maintain a sense of consistency for all of our behaviors. It is a uniquely human endeavor, and upon it rests not only the mechanism that generates our sense of subjective reality but also a mental capacity to free us from the binding controls of external contingencies” (Gazzaniga, 1985, p. 80).

We are meaning making machines. We absorb stimuli from our environments and order it in unique and distorted ways to create our own subjective reality.

Factors that Influence Subjective Reality

Subjective reality is shaped by a variety of factors that influence how individuals perceive and interpret the world around them. Here are some key factors:

• Emotions: How you feel can significantly impact how you interpret the world around you.
• Beliefs and Values: Your beliefs about what is true and your values shape how you perceive reality.
• Past Experiences: Your previous experiences can influence how you perceive similar situations in the present.
• Culture: The culture you are part of provides a lens through which you view the world, influencing your perceptions.
• Physiology: Your sensory organs and brain processes play a role in how you perceive stimuli and construct your reality.
• Cognitive Biases: These are systematic patterns of deviation from norm or rationality in judgment, which affect the decisions and judgments that humans make.
• Context: The context in which you encounter a situation can affect your perception, as can the context of your life at the time.
• Top-Down Processing: This refers to how our brains use what we already know to interpret new information.

Understanding these factors can help us appreciate the complexity of perception and the subjective nature of reality. It’s important to recognize that each person’s reality is unique and influenced by a multitude of personal factors.

Emotions Significant Role in Subjective Reality

Moreover, emotions play a fundamental role in shaping subjective reality. An individual’s emotional state can color their perception of the world, leading to biases and cognitive distortions. For instance, someone feeling anxious may interpret ambiguous situations as threatening, while a person in a positive mood may perceive the same situations as benign. Emotions can have a pervasive impact not only on our outlook towards the external world but also on our internal cognitive processes.

Studies have shown that emotional experiences can influence memory, decision-making, and even our ability to empathize with others. Therefore, gaining a deeper understanding of the intricate interplay between emotions and cognition is essential for comprehending human behavior and interactions. Exploring this intricate connection between emotions and perception provides valuable insights into various aspects of human psychology and provides a foundation for addressing issues related to mental health and interpersonal relationships.

Subjective Interpretations Impact on Futures

Our subjective reality is more than just a momentary framing of the present experience. Our interpretation of an experience is stored, becoming our own personal reality. We than draw upon these stored memories for interpreting new experiences. Our subjective realities reverberate throughout our lives, impacting future experiences. These subjective interpretations leave somatic markers that arise every time a similar event occurs (Damasio, 2005).

See Somatic Markers for more on this topic

Epigenetics and Subjective Interpretations

The concept of epigenetics plays a crucial role in understanding how our emotional experiences shape subjective interpretations of reality. As Bruce Ecker, Robin Ticic, and Laurel Hulley suggest, negative experiences—such as those associated with depression or insecurity—can lead to epigenetic molecular tagging that influences not only gene expression but also the way individuals perceive and interpret their world. They wrote that, “depression- or insecurity-generating experiences, for instance, may drive epigenetic molecular tagging not directly but through the long-lasting negative meanings and constructs that these experiences set up in implicit memory (even in animals). It is these chronically operating, implicit, subjective meanings, we propose, that drive emotional and behavioral responses which, in turn, drive the epigenetic tagging process in a top-down manner” (Ecker et al., 2012).

This means that past traumas or chronic stressors do not merely reside in memory; they become biologically embedded within us, affecting our cognitive processes and interpretations for years to come. The idea that these implicit memories can alter an individual’s perception highlights the complex interplay between biology and psychology.

The Impact of Experience on Genetics

When exploring how emotional experiences affect subjective reality through epigenetics, it becomes evident that our responses to future events are often colored by the emotional weight of past encounters. For instance, someone who has faced repeated rejection may develop a heightened sensitivity to perceived criticism or disapproval. Their brain’s neurobiological systems may be primed by previous trauma to interpret neutral interactions as threatening due to changes in gene expression linked with anxiety and fear responses. Thus, even when encountering similar situations devoid of actual danger, such individuals might react defensively or avoidantly based on their learned associations—a phenomenon intricately tied to their unique biological makeup shaped by earlier life events.

Furthermore, recognizing this relationship fosters a more nuanced approach toward mental health treatment by highlighting the need for personalized strategies addressing both psychological factors and biological underpinnings. Therapeutic interventions could integrate techniques aimed at re-framing negative interpretations while simultaneously considering lifestyle changes that promote positive gene expression through healthy habits like exercise and mindfulness practices. By fostering resilience against adverse experiential impacts on both cognitive function and genetic predisposition over time, individuals can work towards rewriting their narratives—not just psychologically but also at a fundamental biological level—providing hope for healing from deeply ingrained patterns stemming from subjective realities shaped throughout their lives.

See Epigenetics for more on this topic

Beliefs and Cultural Background

Beliefs and cultural background further contribute to shaping subjective reality. Deeply held beliefs and cultural norms can act as filters through which individuals process information. This means that two people from different cultural backgrounds may have contrasting subjective realities, even when experiencing the same events.

Our beliefs and cultural background play a significant role in shaping the way we perceive and interpret the world around us. These deeply ingrained elements act as cognitive filters, influencing our understanding of reality. When individuals encounter the same set of circumstances, their subjective realities may vary greatly due to the unique perspectives shaped by their cultural backgrounds and beliefs. This demonstrates the complex and multifaceted nature of human perception, underscoring the rich diversity of subjective experiences that exist within our global community.

Dynamic Evolution of Subjective Realities

It’s important to note that subjective reality is not fixed and can evolve significantly over time. Personal growth, new experiences, and exposure to diverse perspectives can challenge and ultimately expand an individual’s subjective reality in profound ways. This highlights the malleable nature of our cognitive processes and underscores the immense potential for personal development throughout our lives. Embracing change allows individuals to reshape their understanding of themselves and the world around them, fostering resilience and adaptability in navigating life’s complexities.

Example of Different Perceptions of Same Incident

The Art Exhibition

Anna and Ben, two friends with a shared love for art, visited an exhibition showcasing modern abstract paintings. The centerpiece was a large, vibrant canvas filled with chaotic splashes of color.

Underlying Perspectives and Attitudes

Anna’s Perspective: Anna was immediately captivated. To her, the painting was a burst of emotion on canvas, a representation of the artist’s inner turmoil and passion. She saw the bright reds as symbols of love and the deep blues as depths of sadness. The painting spoke to her; it was a masterpiece of raw, unfiltered expression.

Ben’s Perspective: Ben, on the other hand, was unimpressed. He preferred art with clear structure and recognizable forms. To him, the painting looked like a haphazard mess, a child’s play with paint. He couldn’t understand the praise it received. The colors were just colors, not emotions or stories. He saw no skill or technique, just randomness.

Subjective Experience

The Event’s Aftermath: As they left the exhibition, Anna couldn’t stop talking about the emotional journey the painting took her on. Ben, however, expressed his confusion and dissatisfaction. They had both witnessed the same painting but walked away with completely different experiences and opinions.

This story illustrates how subjective reality is shaped by individual perceptions, emotions, and experiences. Anna and Ben’s differing backgrounds, tastes in art, and personal beliefs led them to interpret the same painting in vastly different ways.

Maladaptive Subjective Realities

Not all subjective interpretations of reality are harmless, just a difference in opinion, as in the above cited example. Some subjective realities is a creation of complex cognitions, displacing or denying elements in our environment that require an appropriate response. Often our subjective realities is a protective construction, utilizing a variety of defense mechanisms such as denial, projection, and displacement that soften the blow of reality to our ego.

Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi suggests having external controls to keep the mind in order. He wrote, “It is probably better that we need ordered external input to keep the mind in order; this way we ensure some congruence between objective and subjective reality. If we could dream up satisfying fantasies regardless of what happened outside our head, we would run into trouble” (Csikszentmihalyi, 2009). Basically, he is suggesting we put external controls, such as objectively measurable goals, written logs, and supportive others, that can help prevent subjective thinking from detouring constructive efforts.

Subjective Realities and Relationships

Emotional attunement requires the ability to see others’ subjective reality. This crucial skill allows individuals to empathize and connect with others on a deeper level, fostering meaningful relationships and understanding. By acknowledging and validating the emotions, perspectives, and experiences of those around us, we can cultivate a supportive and compassionate environment. This, in turn, contributes to emotional well-being and a sense of belonging.

Understanding a partner’s subjective reality in a given moment requires open communication. Guessing isn’t effective. We must make a concerted effort to understand what they see and feel.

Developing emotional attunement is an ongoing process that involves active listening, open-mindedness, and a genuine willingness to comprehend diverse viewpoints. When we strive to understand and resonate with the subjective realities of others, we promote inclusivity, empathy, and harmonious coexistence. Such a conscious effort to attune to the emotions and experiences of others can lead to enriched connections and a more profound appreciation for the complexity of human emotions and relationships. Thus, emotional attunement serves as a cornerstone for building a more empathetic and understanding society.

See Emotional Attunement for more on this topic

Associated Concepts

• Constructivism: Suggests that individuals construct their own understanding and knowledge of the world, through experiencing things and reflecting on those experiences.
• George Kelly’s Personal Construct Theory: Kelly developed this theory in the 1950’s. It deals with the subjective construction of environmental stimuli.
• Phenomenology: Focuses on the subjective experience of individuals and how they make sense of their experiences.
• Perceptual Symbol Theory (PST): This theory provides a framework that posits that all concepts and knowledge are grounded in the sensory and motor systems of the brain.
• Social Constructionism: Argues that much of what we understand as reality is constructed through social processes, language, and cultural context.
• Psychoanalytic Theory: Explores how unconscious motivations and early developmental experiences shape an individual’s perception of reality.
• Cognitive Psychology: Examines how people perceive, think, remember, and learn, which contributes to their subjective reality.
• Humanistic Psychology: Emphasizes personal growth and self-actualization, influencing one’s subjective view of the world.

A Few Words by Psychology Fanatic

In conclusion, subjective reality serves as a multifaceted cognitive process intricately shaped by our perceptions, emotions, beliefs, and cultural backgrounds. By delving into this concept, psychologists can unlock valuable insights into the complexities of human behavior and cognition. Understanding how these elements interact not only enhances our comprehension of individual differences but also allows us to appreciate the rich tapestry of experiences that shape each person’s unique viewpoint. Recognizing that everyone interprets the world through their own lens encourages us to approach others with curiosity rather than judgment.

Moreover, becoming aware of our own subjective realities empowers us on a personal level. This self-awareness fosters empathy for those around us, enabling deeper connections and more meaningful interactions in both personal and professional relationships. As we embrace our journeys of growth and transformation, we open ourselves up to new perspectives that challenge our preconceived notions. Ultimately, acknowledging the fluid nature of subjective reality invites ongoing exploration—both within ourselves and in relation to others—leading to enriched lives filled with understanding and compassion.

References:

Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly (2009). The Evolving Self: Psychology for the Third Millennium. HarperCollins e-books; Reprint edition.
(Return to Article)

Damasio, Antonio (2005). Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain. Penguin Books; Reprint edition.
(Return to Article)

Dubrovsky, David I. (2019). “The Hard Problem of Consciousness”. Theoretical solution of its main questions. AIMS Neuroscience, 6(2), 85-103. DOI: 10.3934/Neuroscience.2019.2.85
(Return to Article)

Ecker, Bruce; Ticic, Robin; Hulley, Laurel (2012). Unlocking the Emotional Brain: Eliminating Symptoms at Their Roots Using Memory Reconsolidation. Routledge; 1st edition.
(Return to Article)

Gazzaniga, Michael S. (1985). Social Brain: Discovering the Networks of the Mind. Basic Books.
(Return to Article)