Understanding Achievement-Goal Theory and its Impact on Motivation
Achievement goals are a fundamental element of success, motivating growth and pushing forward despite various obstacles. Achievement goals are essential in the formation of behavioral intentions, and eventually behaviors. In the 1970’s, a group of researchers presented the Achievement-goal theory. This theory is one of the most popular theoretical frameworks in motivation research.
Achievement-Goal Theory is a psychological framework that examines how individuals’ goals influence their motivation and behavior, particularly in achievement contexts like education or sports. The theory posits that the type of goals individuals set for themselves—whether they are focused on mastering a skill (mastery goals) or on demonstrating competence relative to others (performance goals)—can impact their motivation and the strategies they use to achieve those goals.
Key Definition:
Achievement-Goal Theory is a psychological framework that aims to understand how individuals’ beliefs about competence and the reasons behind their actions influence their behavior and motivation.
History of Achievement-Goal Theory
Achievement-Goal Theory was first developed in the late 1970s. Researchers at the university of Illinois were particularly prominent in early developments of the theory. In particular, Martin, Maehr, Carole Ames, John Nicholls, and Carol Dweck (Anderman & Patrick, 2012). Achievement goal theorists first developed this theory for use in educational settings. However, the theory is now used across several domains.
It began as a way to explain people’s achievement motivation and incorporated various motivational constructs such as attributions, perceived competence, and conceptions of ability. The theory has evolved considerably since its initial conceptualization. Early in its development, John Nicholls identified the constructs of mastery and performance. Later the orientations of approach and avoid were added to the construct, leading to a two by two quadrant model of motivation.
What Are Achievement Goals?
This theory defines achievement goals as future oriented aspiration of desired outcomes. Basically, the goal is formed around an outcome expectancy. These internal goals direct behavior in specific ways, depending on an individual’s foundational orientation. Some individuals are driven to increase competencies. While others may be more interested in demonstrating competencies (Chazan, Pelletier, & Daniels, 2021).
Elaine S. Elliott and Carol Dweck defined an achievement goal as involving a “program” of cognitive processes that have “cognitive, affective, and behavioral consequences” (Elliott & Dweck, 1988).
See Outcome Expectancy for more on this topic
Main Concepts of Achievement Goal Theory
Achievement Goal Types
Carol Ames wrote, “mastery and performance goals represent different conceptions of success and different reasons for approaching and engaging in achievement activity and involve different ways of thinking about oneself, one’s task, and task outcomes” (Ames, 1992).
1. Mastery Goals
Mastery goals emphasize the development of competence and the acquisition of new knowledge or skills, without necessarily comparing oneself to others. This orientation is often associated with a focus on learning and improvement rather than on performance outcomes. In psychology, we often refer to this motivation as intrinsic motivation.
“Results of numerous studies indicate that when students focus on mastery, they tend to be willing to think deeply and broadly about their academic work; they use effective learning and self-regulatory strategies, including monitoring their comprehension and thinking about how current academic tasks are related to previously learned information” (Anderman, Patrick, & Ha, 2012).
2. Performance Goals
Performance goals revolve around demonstrating competence, often in comparison to others. Individuals with this orientation may be motivated by achieving favorable judgments and outperforming their peers. In psychology, we refer to this as extrinsically motivated. Performance goals have more mixed associations with achievement.
Orientation Styles
1. Approach
In achievement goal theory, an approach orientation refers to the motivation to engage in a task with the goal of achieving a positive outcome or demonstrating competence. It contrasts with an avoidance orientation, which involves engaging in a task to avoid a negative outcome or the perception of incompetence.
Specifically, within the framework of achievement goal theory, approach orientations can be further divided into:
- Mastery-Approach Goals: These involve striving to improve one’s own abilities and learn new skills. Success is defined in terms of personal improvement and mastery of the task.
- Performance-Approach Goals: These involve striving to outperform others and demonstrate one’s abilities relative to others. Success is defined in terms of social comparison and being better than others.
The approach orientation is associated with positive outcomes such as increased persistence, enjoyment, and engagement in the task.
2. Avoid
In achievement goal theory, an avoidance orientation refers to the motivation to engage in a task with the goal of avoiding a negative outcome or the perception of incompetence. This orientation is characterized by a desire to avoid failure, criticism, or unfavorable judgments about one’s abilities.
Avoidance orientation can be further divided into two categories:
- Performance-Avoidance Goals: These involve striving to avoid performing worse than others and to prevent showing a lack of ability. Individuals with performance-avoidance goals are motivated by the fear of negative evaluations and comparisons with others.
- Mastery-Avoidance Goals: These goals focus on avoiding misunderstanding or the failure to master a task. Accordingly, they involve a concern over falling short of one’s own standards or past performances.
While we generally associate approach orientations with positive outcomes, avoidance orientations can lead to increased anxiety, fear of failure, and a tendency to disengage from challenging tasks. Understanding these orientations can help educators and psychologists develop strategies to foster more adaptive, approach-oriented goals in educational and achievement contexts.
See Fear of Failure for more on this topic
The approach and avoid orientations share similarities with Jeffrey Gray’s behavioral activation and behavioral inhibition systems. Gray (1981, 1987) suggested that different neurologically-based, independent systems are involved in regulating behavior. One is the Behavioral Activation System, activated by appetitive rewards to conditioned and unconditioned stimuli. The second is the Behavioral Inhibition System, activated by conditioned and unconditioned stimuli signaling punishment or non-reward.
See Behavioral Activation System for more on this topic
The Two by Two Model
The theory has evolved, combining the two goal types of mastery and performance, with the approach and avoid responses. Theorists often presented achievement goal theory with a two by two model.
The four sections of the quadrant are:
- Mastery-Approach Goals: Striving to improve, learn, and develop competence.
- Mastery-Avoidance Goals: Focusing on not falling short of one’s standards.
- Performance-Approach Goals: Aiming to outperform others and demonstrate superior ability.
- Performance-Avoidance Goals: Trying to avoid doing worse than others or appearing incompetent.
Achievement Goal Theory suggests that mastery goals, especially mastery-approach goals, are generally associated with more positive outcomes, such as greater intrinsic motivation and persistence, while performance-avoidance goals can be linked to negative outcomes like anxiety and avoidance of challenging tasks.
Examples of the Different Orientations
Here are examples for each orientation within the achievement goal theory:
- Mastery-Approach Orientation: A student who chooses to take an advanced course not because they need to, but because they want to deepen their understanding of the subject. Their desire for self-improvement and learning drives their behavior.
- Mastery-Avoidance Orientation: An athlete who trains rigorously not merely to improve but also to avoid falling short of their personal best performances. Accordingly, fear of not mastering the task or failing to live up to their own standards motivates their behavior.
- Performance-Approach Orientation: A salesperson who aims to be the top seller in their company, not just to earn the commission, but also to gain recognition and status among their peers. Their desire outperform others and demonstrate their superiority is their key motivator.
- Performance-Avoidance Orientation: A public speaker who prepares extensively for a presentation to avoid the embarrassment of forgetting their lines or being perceived as incompetent by the audience. Their primary motivation is to evade negative judgment and appear competent.
Associated Psychology Theories
Research associates Achievement-Goal Theory with several psychological theories that focus on motivation, learning, and performance. Here are some of the key theories:
- Self-Determination Theory: This theory emphasizes the role of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in driving achievement behaviors.
- Expectancy-Value Theory: It suggests that individuals’ beliefs about their ability to perform a task and the value they place on success predict their achievement goals.
- Attribution Theory: This theory examines how individuals explain their successes and failures, which can influence their achievement goals.
- Self-Worth Theory: This theory suggests that individuals seek out validation from others or avoid situations that could potentially damage their self-esteem.
- Learned Helplessness: In this theory the concept of learned helplessness refers to a cognitive state of giving up because one believes their efforts have no impact on the end result.
- Self-Efficacy Theory: Developed by Bandura, it focuses on the belief in one’s capabilities to execute actions required to manage prospective situations, affecting the types of goals they set.
- Implicit Theories of Intelligence: Carol Dweck’s work on fixed and growth mindsets relates to how individuals’ beliefs about intelligence affect their achievement goals and motivation.
- Goal Setting Theory: This theory looks at the relationship between setting specific and challenging goals and task performance.
These theories contribute to our understanding of how different factors, such as motivation, beliefs about intelligence, and goal setting, interact to influence individuals’ achievement goals and behaviors.
Applications of Achievement-Goal Theory
Achievement Goal Theory has practical applications in various domains, particularly in education, sports, and organizational settings. Here are some examples:
- Education: Educators can use Achievement Goal Theory to foster a learning environment that promotes mastery goals over performance goals, encouraging students to focus on learning and understanding rather than just achieving high grades. This can lead to improved student engagement, motivation, and a positive classroom climate.
- Sports: Coaches can apply the theory to help athletes set appropriate goals, focusing on personal skill development (mastery goals) rather than just winning (performance goals). This approach can enhance motivation and performance in sports.
- Workplace: In organizational settings, managers can use the theory to create a work environment that emphasizes personal growth and mastery. This can lead to increased job satisfaction, motivation, and productivity among employees.
- Psychological Interventions: Psychologists and counselors can use Achievement Goal Theory to help individuals set and pursue goals that lead to personal growth and fulfillment, contributing to better mental health outcomes.
These applications show how program directors, educators and supervisors can use achievement goal theory to understand and influence motivation and behavior in various contexts, leading to more effective strategies for achieving personal and collective goals.
A Few Words by Psychology Fanatic
In conclusion, Achievement-Goal Theory provides an insightful framework for understanding and explaining individuals’ motivation and behavior in achievement settings. By delineating the different types of goals individuals pursue and the impact of these goals on their cognition, affect, and behavior, this theory offers valuable implications for educators, coaches, and managers. Understanding the interplay between mastery and performance goals, as well as the adaptive and maladaptive strategies associated with each, can inform the development of effective motivational interventions. As we continue to delve into the complexities of human motivation, this theory remains a prominent and influential construct in the field of psychology and beyond.
Last Update: April 14, 2024
References:
Ames, Carol (1992). Classrooms: Goals, Structures, and Student Motivation. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84(3), 261-271. DOI: 10.1037/0022-0663.84.3.261
Anderman, E.M., Patrick, H., Ha, S.Y. (2012). Achievement Goal Theory and Engagement. In: Reschly, A.L., Christenson, S.L. (eds) Handbook of Research on Student Engagement. Springer, Cham. Link
Chazan, Devon; Pelletier, Gabriella; Daniels, Lia. (2021). Achievement Goal Theory Review: An Application to School Psychology: . Canadian Journal of School Psychology,37(1), 40-56. DOI: 10.1177/08295735211058319
Dweck, Carol; Leggett, Ellen (1988). A Social–Cognitive Approach to Motivation and Personality. Psychological Review, 95(2), 256-273. DOI: 10.1037/0033-295X.95.2.256
Elliott, Elaine; Dweck, Carol (1988). Goals: An Approach to Motivation and Achievement. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,54(1), 5-12. DOI: 10.1037/0022-3514.54.1.5
Gray, Jeffrey Allen (1981) Critique of Eysenck’s Theory of Personality. In A Model for Personality, Editor HJ. Eysenck.
Gray, Jeffrey A. (1987). Perspectives on anxiety and impulsivity: A commentary. Journal of Research in Personality, 21(4), 493–509. DOI: 10.1016/0092-6566(87)90036-5
Urdan, T., & Kaplan, A. (2020). The origins, evolution, and future directions of achievement goal theory. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 61, Article 101862. DOI: 10.1016/j.cedpsych.2020.101862
Resources and Articles
Please visit Psychology Fanatic’s vast selection of articles, definitions and database of referenced books.
Topic Specific Databases:
PSYCHOLOGY – EMOTIONS – RELATIONSHIPS – WELLNESS – PSYCHOLOGY TOPICS
