My old Corolla still runs just as well as it did before after my neighbor bought her new car. The Corolla still carries the groceries, starts on cold mornings, and gets me where I need to go. Yet when parked in the driveway beside my neighbor’s polished new vehicle, this same dependable car suddenly feel like evidence that I am falling behind. Nothing about the old Corolla’s usefulness has changed. My measure of its value has.
Relative deprivation helps explain this shift. Comparisons can reveal a genuine injustice, or they can make an adequate life feel painfully insufficient. Understanding the difference allows us to examine our dissatisfaction without dismissing either our feelings or the conditions that deserve to change.
Table of Contents
What Relative Deprivation Means
We rarely assess our lives in isolation. A salary, an achievement, or a home acquires meaning partly through the standards surrounding it. Leon Festinger’s social comparison theory proposed that people evaluate their opinions and abilities through comparison with others, especially when clear objective standards are unavailable (Festinger, 1954). This theory helps explain why another person can become a reference point for judging ourselves.
Relative deprivation adds a further judgment. We see a disadvantage and believe that we should not have to bear it. Heather J. Smith and Yuen J. Huo (2014) emphasize that the experience involves a sense of undeserved inequality. Seeing a colleague’s larger office is an observation. Believing that equally deserving employees are being treated unfairly gives that observation a different emotional meaning.
The distinction separates relative deprivation from ordinary wanting. We may admire a beautiful house, envy its owner, or feel inspired to pursue a similar goal without believing we have been wronged. Envy and relative deprivation can overlap, but the judgment of unfair disadvantage is central to the latter (Smith et al., 2012). The Corolla example begins with comparison; it becomes relative deprivation when we experience our position as less than we believe we deserve.
The experience develops through more than a visible difference. We compare our position with a relevant standard, see the disadvantage as undeserved, and experience an emotional response, often anger or resentment. The particular emotions and perceived opportunities for change help explain whether people seek a personal improvement, join a shared challenge, or withdraw (Smith & Huo, 2014). This helps explain why two people facing a similar gap may react differently.
Relative and absolute deprivation can also coexist. Someone struggling to afford food may experience both material hardship and resentment at unequal access to basic resources. Someone with considerable wealth may feel deprived beside a richer peer. The word relative identifies the comparison involved. It does not establish whether a person’s needs are met or whether the inequality is justified.
Why the Comparison Group Matters
A comparison has particular force when the other person seems relevant to our own life. A coworker who entered the organization with us may become a more compelling standard than a distant celebrity. We have some reason to imagine that their opportunities could have been ours. The choice of reference point helps determine what we experience as a reasonable expectation (Smith & Huo, 2014).
The history of relative deprivation illustrates this problem. Smith and colleagues (2012) describe Samuel Stouffer’s work with American soldiers during World War II: Air Corps personnel expressed greater frustration about promotion than military police, even though promotion was faster in the Air Corps. Stouffer proposed that airmen were comparing themselves with peers who had advanced. More opportunity could therefore create more visible occasions for feeling left behind. The explanation was inferred from the survey findings; the original researchers did not directly measure relative deprivation.
Our own standards can shift in a similar way. A promotion may bring us into a circle where the income we once hoped for looks ordinary. A new home may place us beside homes that make ours seem modest. Improvement remains real, but its emotional meaning changes when the comparison changes.
In The Paradox of Choice, Barry Schwartz (2005) explores how satisfaction depends partly on expectations and social comparisons. He also notes that looking upward can inspire us as well as discourage us. Another person’s success carries no single inevitable message. We interpret it through our expectations, the opportunities we believe are available, and the meaning we give to the difference.
Consumer Culture and the Moving Standard of Enough
The car in the opening example has a practical purpose, but it can also become a public measure of success. We may begin by wanting reliable transportation and end by wanting a vehicle that says we are doing well. Once possession carries that burden, another purchase can make the earlier one feel inadequate.
Clive Hamilton and Richard Denniss (2005), in Affluenza, describe a consumer culture in which rising desires repeatedly outpace greater affluence. Their argument is a social critique of consumption and dissatisfaction, rather than proof that every purchase diminishes happiness. It helps us ask what we are expecting a possession to accomplish: meet a need, offer pleasure, or settle an uneasy question about our worth.
Research on materialistic priorities provides a more specific connection. Emily Polak and Michael McCullough (2006) reviewed evidence linking a stronger emphasis on possessions with poorer well-being and reported small negative associations between trait gratitude and materialistic striving. Their evidence does not show that gratitude causes materialism to decline, but it supports examining how much importance we place on acquisition when judging a good life.
Schwartz (2005) makes a related point about competition for status. Some rewards depend on relative position, so everyone cannot occupy the highest rank at once. If feeling successful requires staying ahead of others, greater collective prosperity will not necessarily bring an equivalent sense of personal sufficiency.
There is nothing inherently misguided about enjoying a new car. The difficulty begins when someone else’s purchase cancels the value of what already serves us. A dependable Corolla may still be dependable. Its modest appearance tells us little about the quality of our relationships, the care we offer others, or the purposes guiding our days.
Individual and Group Relative Deprivation
Researchers distinguish individual relative deprivation from group relative deprivation. Individual deprivation concerns how I am doing compared with another person or another version of my own circumstances. Group deprivation concerns how a group I belong to is treated compared with another group. We can experience one without the other (Smith & Huo, 2014).
For example, an employee may resent being passed over while a similarly qualified coworker advances. That is an individual comparison. The same employee may notice that people from their ethnic community are consistently excluded from advancement. The second comparison concerns a shared disadvantage. A person can be personally successful and still recognize that their group is treated unfairly.
A review of 210 studies involving 186,073 respondents found that these distinctions helped explain people’s responses. Feeling personally left behind was more closely linked with individual outcomes, while feeling that our group was disadvantaged was more closely linked with shared action. The findings were stronger when researchers asked about feelings of unfairness, rather than simply recording that someone had less (Smith et al., 2012).
Shared resentment may support efforts toward fairer treatment. It can also accompany hostility toward other groups; dissatisfaction does not automatically produce an accurate explanation or a constructive response (Smith & Huo, 2014). We still need to examine the evidence for an injustice, who is responsible, and what kind of action would address it.
Comparison can therefore expose unequal treatment that would otherwise remain hidden. Yet relief from resentment is not proof that an inequality has been corrected. Smith and Huo (2014) note that respectful treatment and fair procedures can soften responses even when substantive inequities persist. We need to ask both how people are feeling and what has actually changed in their access to resources or opportunity.
Relative Deprivation and Well-Being
Feeling repeatedly and unfairly left behind can reach beyond a passing disappointment. Smith and Huo (2014) review evidence linking relative deprivation with poorer mental and physical health, including distress in people who interpret a difficult situation as worse than that of relevant others. Their account emphasizes how emotions and perceived opportunities for change shape responses to disadvantage.
A newer study gives this connection more detail. Ahhyun Cho and Harris Hyun-soo Kim (2024) analyzed three South Korean surveys collected in 2017 and 2018. Across all three, the association between greater disadvantage and lower happiness was stronger among people who regarded society as more unfair. For life satisfaction, however, this pattern appeared only in the national survey, rather than consistently across all three datasets.
The surveys asked people where they believed they stood in society or how unstable their economic circumstances felt. They did not directly ask which comparisons people were making or how resentful they felt. Because each survey captured one moment in time, the findings cannot tell us which experience came first. Lower happiness might affect how people judge their circumstances, just as their circumstances might affect happiness. The study does not show that encouraging people to view society as fairer would improve their well-being (Cho & Kim, 2024).
The broader health evidence raises a separate caution. Associations with poorer mental or physical health do not establish that comparison alone causes illness. Material conditions, discrimination, existing health difficulties, and access to support may also matter. Smith and colleagues (2012) identify unresolved questions about the pathways connecting relative deprivation with specific health outcomes.
Responding Without Dismissing What Matters
The practical task begins with understanding the particular sense of lack. What exactly feels missing? Compared with whom? What makes the difference seem unfair? The answers help us consider what would make the situation better.
The Corolla offers a simple illustration. If it is unreliable or unsafe, the concern involves a practical need. If it works well but seems embarrassing beside a neighbor’s car, the discomfort may concern the meaning we attach to status. If an employer distributes opportunities unfairly, the comparison may reveal a barrier that deserves to change. These concerns can overlap; recognizing one does not cancel the others.
Examining what a feeling is telling us can help us choose a response suited to the concern. Appreciation may restore the value of a useful possession, but it cannot repair a dangerous vehicle or correct an unfair promotion decision. The following reflections bring together the comparison research and motivational perspectives discussed here; they are not a tested treatment protocol.
Examine the Whole Comparison
A car reveals very little about a household’s finances. We see the vehicle without seeing the payments, savings, obligations, or priorities surrounding it. Even an accurate comparison of cars would remain an incomplete comparison of lives. Before allowing one visible advantage to become a verdict on our worth, we can ask what information we actually possess.
We can also return to the purpose of the thing we are judging. Does the car still meet our needs? Would replacing it serve an important goal, or mainly relieve the discomfort of appearing less successful? Hamilton and Denniss (2005) encourage this kind of conscious examination of consumption. The answer can support either a considered purchase or renewed appreciation for what we already have.
For an ordinary status comparison, it may help to ask what purpose an improvement would serve. Would a different car provide safety, comfort, or freedom to travel? Would it mainly reassure us that we look successful? A clear purpose gives us a standard we can examine alongside the comparison.
Edward Deci and Richard Ryan (2000), writing about self-determination theory, separate what we want from why we want it. Their review links goals such as close relationships, personal growth, and community contribution with experiences of connection, capability, and choice. Giving greater priority to wealth, fame, or image has different links with well-being. The point is to examine what we expect an achievement to provide, as well as whether we freely endorse the pursuit. Earning more may serve an important need without becoming the measure of our worth.
Let Appreciation Coexist with Ambition
Gratitude offers another way of attending to our circumstances. Wood and colleagues (2010) describe it broadly as noticing and appreciating positive aspects of life. In the context of comparison, that perspective invites us to notice benefits that have become familiar: the car that still works, the friend who remains available, or the freedom a manageable expense allows. We can appreciate reliable transportation while wanting better pay.
There is evidence for modest benefits from gratitude practices. A review combining results from 145 papers found small average improvements in well-being, with effects varying across countries and study characteristics (Choi et al., 2025). That supports gratitude as one possible resource for well-being, while leaving open whether it reduces relative deprivation. Polak and McCullough’s (2006) findings also leave that question unresolved.
Appreciation can accompany ambition without becoming a demand to feel fortunate about every circumstance. We can value what already supports us while remaining honest about what is missing.
Give Genuine Unfairness an Appropriate Response
When a concern involves unequal treatment, we may need information, support, and a practical avenue for change. A workplace grievance, for example, calls for attention to the decisions and opportunities involved. Looking closely at the evidence can clarify whether the comparison reveals a pattern or leaves important facts unknown.
Smith and Huo (2014) propose that beliefs about a system’s openness to change help channel resentment into different forms of action. Having a voice and access to procedures through which errors can be corrected may make constructive action seem more possible. Connecting with others who understand the situation may also help us examine it more fully and consider a response.
The aim is to give a legitimate concern an effective response. Gratitude should never become a reason to silence it, and feeling calmer should not be mistaken for evidence that the underlying treatment is fair.
A Few Words from Psychology Fanatic
We compare. We learn from observations, and sometimes another person’s life helps us imagine a worthwhile possibility for our own. Yet our comparing mind can also turn useful possessions and ordinary comforts into reminders of what we lack. The feeling deserves our attention without receiving the final word.
The Corolla is still waiting in the driveway. Perhaps it needs replacing; perhaps it needs only to be seen again for what it offers. We can make that judgment with greater honesty when the neighbor’s purchase no longer decides it for us.
We can cherish what supports our lives and keep working toward what would improve them. We can recognize injustice and still notice kindness. There is room to pursue a fairer future without allowing every comparison to take the good of the present away.
Associated Concepts
- Gratitude: An emotion, disposition, or practice of noticing and appreciating benefits and support. It can keep present value visible alongside unmet needs.
- Self-Esteem: Our overall sense of personal worth. A narrow comparison of possessions or achievements need not become a judgment about the value of a whole person.
- Self-Categorization Theory: An account of how people understand themselves as individuals and group members. It helps explain the shift from personal disadvantage to shared grievance.
- Perception: The process of organizing and interpreting information. Relative deprivation depends partly on the meaning assigned to a difference in circumstances.
- SMART Goals: Goals framed as specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. They offer a way to clarify a desired improvement beyond the indefinite aim of keeping up.
- Self-Compassion: Responding to difficulty with kindness, recognition of shared humanity, and balanced awareness. It can provide a perspective on disappointment without condemning the whole self.
References
Cho, Ahhyun; Kim, Harris Hyun-soo (2024). Perceived Unfairness Moderates the Association Between Relative Deprivation and Subjective Well-Being: Findings from an East Asian Country. Applied Research in Quality of Life, 19(5), 2417–2446. DOI: 10.1007/s11482-024-10336-7.
(Return to Main Text)
Choi, Hyewon; Cha, Youngjae; McCullough, Michael E.; Coles, Nicholas A.; Oishi, Shigehiro (2025). A Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Gratitude Interventions on Well-Being Across Cultures. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(28), e2425193122. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2425193122.
(Return to Main Text)
Deci, Edward L.; Ryan, Richard M. (2000). The “What” and “Why” of Goal Pursuits: Human Needs and the Self-Determination of Behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268. DOI: 10.1207/S15327965PLI1104_01.
(Return to Main Text)
Festinger, Leon (1954). A Theory of Social Comparison Processes. Human Relations, 7(2), 117–140. DOI: 10.1177/001872675400700202.
(Return to Main Text)
Hamilton, Clive; Denniss, Richard (2005). Affluenza: When Too Much Is Never Enough. Allen & Unwin. ISBN: 9781741146714.
(Return to Main Text)
Polak, Emily L.; McCullough, Michael E. (2006). Is Gratitude an Alternative to Materialism? Journal of Happiness Studies, 7, 343–360. DOI: 10.1007/s10902-005-3649-5.
(Return to Main Text)
Schwartz, Barry (2005). The Paradox of Choice: Why More Is Less. Harper Perennial. ISBN: 9780060005696.
(Return to Main Text)
Smith, Heather J.; Huo, Yuen J. (2014). Relative Deprivation: How Subjective Experiences of Inequality Influence Social Behavior and Health. Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 1(1), 231–238. DOI: 10.1177/2372732214550165.
(Return to Main Text)
Smith, Heather J.; Pettigrew, Thomas F.; Pippin, Gina M.; Bialosiewicz, Silvana (2012). Relative Deprivation: A Theoretical and Meta-Analytic Review. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(3), 203–232. DOI: 10.1177/1088868311430825.
(Return to Main Text)
Wood, Alex M.; Froh, Jeffrey J.; Geraghty, Adam W. A. (2010). Gratitude and Well-Being: A Review and Theoretical Integration. Clinical Psychology Review, 30(7), 890–905. DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2010.03.005.
(Return to Main Text)
Last Update: November 4, 2026

